TASK 2 (Discuss both views): Leadership

Some people think that some individuals are naturally good leaders while others think individuals can learn leadership skills. Discuss both views and give your opinion.

Sample Answer

There has been ongoing contentious debate as to whether or not leadership traits are endowed. While one opinion holds that individuals are naturally born leaders, others contend that leadership-related skills can be honed through training and conscientiousness. This essay will therefore discuss both perspectives before stating my final stance on this discourse.

Proponents of a genetic predisposition to leadership capacity may rightly point to numerous examples of young and respected leaders across various domains. These advocates might cite instances from early periods of human civilisation to contemporary societies, ranging from ancient monarchies to modern enterprises. From the public’s perspective, young and often inexperienced kings and queens can handle sophisticated political affairs and command thousands of soldiers, while corporate leaders are able to direct business operations and seamlessly facilitate cross-department collaboration. While there can potentially be a hereditary factor at play, this perhaps only accounts for a minority of exceedingly successful leaders. Against the backdrop of naturally good leaders, there is a multitude of other variables, including abundant latent assistance, a highly supportive environment, and proximity to “real” leaders that contribute to the enhanced cultivation of leadership qualities.

At the other end of the spectrum, opponents of genetically inclined factors argue that leadership is rather a learnable skill. These detractors contend that, in a similar fashion to critical thinking, original problem-solving, or negotiation, the ability to lead can be properly nurtured through the adoption of a highly structured framework encompassing the participation of all stakeholders. Starting from the familial unit, during childhood, the formative phase of one’s life, a child can learn how to lead by not only taking care of their siblings but also engaging them in the organisation and delegation of household activities. Contrary to popular belief, success in these activities during psychodevelopmental years can enable children to command respect from their siblings and acquaintances, thereby contributing to their becoming greater leaders later in life. When children enter formal education, they can embrace leadership through a diverse range of activities, from small-scale group assignments to elaborate projects. By learning conflict resolution, task delegation, and time optimisation, they may gradually emerge as effective leaders, garnering respect and esteem from those around them. Leadership cultivation does not culminate in the academic domain but extends to the workplace, where graduates exercise all the skills they have acquired throughout the years to cooperate with others and win trust. Through this process, they may earn respect and esteem from colleagues, which can steadily propel them into leadership positions.

In conclusion, while I acknowledge the possible hereditary factors inherent in the emergence of innate leaders, this argument may only be applicable to a minority of the population and should not be simplistically generalised to the masses. Upon weighing both viewpoints, I personally lean towards nurtured leadership. Admittedly, those born with endowed leadership qualities may possess an initial advantage; nevertheless, in the absence of consistency, perseverance, and mentorship, these initial budding talents cannot blossom into competent leaders who can contribute to society in a profound way. Ultimately, leadership, similar to other qualities, should be recognised and cultivated from a young age through a concerted effort by all stakeholders, involving family, school, and government. Through a judiciously planned educational framework, familial support, and government funding, such talents can be given fertile ground to flourish rather than falling into obsolescence.

Vocabulary

ongoing contentious debatecuộc tranh luận gây tranh cãi kéo dài
leadership-related skillskỹ năng liên quan đến lãnh đạo
genetic predispositionkhuynh hướng bẩm sinh
various domainsnhiều lĩnh vực
early periods of human civilisationnhững giai đoạn đầu của nền văn minh nhân loại
ancient monarchiescác chế độ quân chủ cổ đại
modern enterprisesdoanh nghiệp hiện đại
sophisticated political affairscông việc/chính sự phức tạp
direct business operationsđiều hành hoạt động kinh doanh
cross-department collaborationhợp tác liên phòng ban
naturally good leadersnhững nhà lãnh đạo bẩm sinh
learnable skillkỹ năng có thể học được
critical thinkingtư duy phản biện
original problem-solvinggiải quyết vấn đề sáng tạo
highly structured frameworkkhuôn khổ có cấu trúc chặt chẽ
all stakeholderstất cả các bên liên quan
familial unitđơn vị gia đình
popular beliefquan niệm phổ biến
diverse range of activitiesnhiều loại hoạt động đa dạng
small-scale group assignmentsbài tập nhóm quy mô nhỏ
time optimisationtối ưu hóa thời gian
weighing both viewpointscân nhắc cả hai quan điểm
endowed leadership qualitiesphẩm chất lãnh đạo bẩm sinh
consistency, perseverance, and mentorshipsự kiên định, kiên trì và cố vấn
concerted effortnỗ lực phối hợp

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *